Steiner-Vallentyne School: Difference between revisions

From Polcompball Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Content added Content deleted
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(36 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:
|themecolor=#fd1908
|themecolor=#fd1908
|textcolor=#070829
|textcolor=#070829
|title=[[File:Steinval.png]] Steiner-Vallentyne School
|title=[[File:Steinval.png]] '''Steiner-Vallentyne School'''
|image=Steiner-Vallentyne_School.png
|image=Steiner-Vallentyne_School.png
|aliases={{Collapse|
|aliases={{Collapse|
Line 14: Line 14:
}}
}}
|alignments=
|alignments=
[[File:CentreLibLeft.png]] [[:Category:Centrists|Centre-]][[:Category:Libertarian Left|LibLeft]]<br>
[[File:CentreLibLeft.png]] [[:Category:Centrists|{{Color|#C0C0C0|'''Centre-'''}}]][[:Category:Libertarian Left|{{Color|#C9E5BD|'''LibLeft'''}}]]<br>
[[File:Prgess.png]] [[:Category:Culturally Left|Culturally Left]]<br>
{{Info|Culturally Left}}<br>
{{Info|Liberals}}<br>
{{Info|Liberals}}<br>
{{Info|Libertarians}}<br>
{{Info|Libertarians}}<br>
{{Info|Georgists}}<br>
{{Info|Georgists}}<br>
{{Info|Welfarists}}
{{Info|Welfarists}}<br>
[[File:L-lib.png]] [[Left-Liberalism (Disambiguation)|{{Color|#F9BABA|'''Left-'''}}{{Color|#C9E5BD|'''Wing'''}} {{Color|#006AA7|'''Liberals'''}}]]<br>
|influences=
|influences=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">
[[File:Analytic.png]] [[mh:philosophyball:Analytic Philosophy|Analytic Philosophy]]<br>
[[File:Analytic.png]] {{PHB|Analytic Philosophy}}<br>
[[File:Bhl.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism]]<br>
[[File:Bhl.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism]]<br>
[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]<br>
[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]<br>
[[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism]]<br>
[[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism]]<br>
[[File:LeftBert.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Left-Libertarianism]]<br>[[File:Socgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism]]<br>
[[File:LeftBert.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Left-Libertarianism]]<br>
[[File:Socliber.png]] [[Social Libertarianism]]
[[File:Socgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism]]<br>
[[File:Socliber.png]] [[Social Libertarianism]]<br>
</div>
|influenced=
|influenced=
|theorists=
|theorists=
[[File:PanAmer.png]] '''Americas''' {{Collapse|
⚫
*[[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]] (1942-) [[File:Cball-Canada.png]] Canada
*David Ellerman (1943-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA
*[[File:Socgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|David Ellerman]] (1943-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*Philippe Van Parijs (1951-) [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] Belgium
*[[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]] (1952-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]] (1952-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA
*[[File:Bertsoc.png]] [[Liberal Socialism|Michael Otsuka]] (1964-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
}}
*Michael Otsuka (1964-) [[File:Cball-US.png]] USA
[[File:Cball-Commonwealth.png]] '''Commonwealth Realm''' {{Collapse|
|likes=
⚫
*[[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]] (1942-) [[File:Cball-Canada.png]] {{PBW|Canadaball|Canada}}
}}
[[File:Cball-EU.png]] '''Europe''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism|Philippe Van Parijs]] (1951-) [[File:Cball-Belgium.png]] {{PBW|Belgiumball|Belgium}}
}}
|likes=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">
[[File:Civlibert.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism|Self-ownership]]<br>
[[File:Civlibert.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism|Self-ownership]]<br>
[[File:Welf.png]] [[Welfarism|Welfare]]<br>
[[File:Welf.png]] [[Welfarism|Welfare]]<br>
[[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism|Henry George]]<br>
[[File:GeoClib.png]] [[Georgism|Henry George]]<br>
[[File:JohnLocke.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|John Locke]]
[[File:JohnLocke.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|John Locke]]<br>
[[File:Globcap.png]] Free Trade
|dislikes=
</div>
⚫
[[File:Timocracy.png]] [[Timocracy|Ownership of land and natural resources]]
|dislikes=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">
⚫
[[File:Timocracy.png]] [[Timocracy|Ownership of land and natural resources]]<br>
</div>
}}
{{Quote|
quote="If one also grants the importance of equality of life prospects, then equal opportunity left-libertarianism is, I claim, the most plausible version of libertarianism."
|speaker=[[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
}}
}}
The '''Steiner-Vallentyne School''' is a [[File:LeftBert.png]] [[:Category:Libertarian Left|Left Libertarian]] ideological school of thought. It bases its support for economically left-wing ideals in [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Classical Liberal]], [[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism|Georgist]], and [[File:Physiocracypix.png]] [[Physiocracy|Physiocratic]] ideas on self-ownership, land appropriation, land ownership and the ownership of natural resources. It opposes the ownership of natural resources and land if such ownership acts as a detriment to others, and believes in state welfare programs and some form of wealth redistribution. Unlike many schools of left-libertarianism, the Steiner-Vallentyne school is not [[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism|socialist]], [[File:Commie.png]] [[Marxism|communist]], or [[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|anarchist]], as it is more moderate in its economically left-wing views.
The '''Steiner-Vallentyne School''' is a [[File:LeftBert.png]] [[:Category:Libertarian Left|Left Libertarian]] ideological school of thought. It bases its support for economically left-wing ideals in [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Classical Liberal]], [[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism|Georgist]], and [[File:Physiocracypix.png]] [[Physiocracy|Physiocratic]] ideas on self-ownership, land appropriation, land ownership and the ownership of natural resources. It opposes the ownership of natural resources and land if such ownership acts as a detriment to others, and believes in state welfare programs and some form of wealth redistribution. Unlike many schools of left-libertarianism, the Steiner-Vallentyne school is not [[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism|socialist]], [[File:Commie.png]] [[Marxism|communist]], or [[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism|anarchist]], as it is more moderate in its economically left-wing views.


==History==
==History==
Steiner Vallentyne School was developed by the ideas of Peter Vallentyne and Hilel Steiner who used Analytic Philosophy in order to solve solve issues regarding the apparent extremism of Libertarian Socialism[[File:Libsoc.png]]. Now despite being very similar to Libertarian Social Georgism[[File:BertSocGeo.png]] it is quite different in terms of in terms of origins as Steiner Vallentyne School was from mixing thoughts from Liberal ideologies and such. Also it is a separate ideology while Libertarian Social Georgism is a faction of Social Libertarianism.
W.I.P.


==How to draw==
==How to draw==
Line 61: Line 77:
*[[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism]] - Fellow left libertarian who agrees with me on land policy. A big inspiration.
*[[File:Georgist.png]] [[Georgism]] - Fellow left libertarian who agrees with me on land policy. A big inspiration.
*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] - John Locke was pretty great.
*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] - John Locke was pretty great.
*[[File:Ricardosoc.png]] [[Ricardian Socialism]] - A left-wing version of the above.
*[[File:Civlibert.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism]] - Full self ownership!
*[[File:Civlibert.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism]] - Full self ownership!
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] and [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism]] - Say yes to self-ownership and no to private property!
*[[File:Mutalist.png]] [[Mutualism]] and [[File:Anmark2.png]] [[Left-Wing Market Anarchism]] - Say yes to self-ownership and no to private property!
*[[File:Geolib.png]] [[Geolibertarianism]] - Me but without welfare still based despite that.
*Liberaltarianism- Mixing liberalism and libertarianism is wise.
*[[File:Civnat.png]] [[Civic Nationalism]]- A actually decent nationalist! I like you more than LibSoc


===Frenemies===
===Frenemies===
*[[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism]] - Sorry, but I think this might be a bit too far.
*[[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism]] - Sorry, but I think this might be a bit too far.
*[[File:Soclib.png]] [[Social Liberalism]] - We both try to combined [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|the principles of classical liberalism]] with [[File:Equality.png]] egalitarian outcomes, but positive rights are a bit of a headache.
*[[File:Soclib.png]] [[Social Liberalism]] - We both try to combined [[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|the principles of classical liberalism]] with [[File:Equality.png]] egalitarian outcomes, but positive rights are a bit of a headache.
*[[File:Angeo.png]] [[Geoanarchism]] - I'm not so sure about how you can maintain common land ownership in a stateless society, but it's the though that counts. Also, please be less friendly with [[File:Ancapf.png]] him.
*[[File:Angeo.png]] [[Geoanarchism]] - I'm not so sure about how you can maintain common land ownership in a stateless society, but it's the thought that counts. Also, please be less friendly with [[File:Ancapf.png]] him.
*[[File:Agsoc.png]] [[Agrarian Socialism]] - I want land reform, too. But I don't think that socialism is necessary for that.

*[[File:3princ.png]] [[Tridemism]] - A little too authoritarian for me, but at least you were better than who came before you and especially those who came after you.
*[[File:Cap.png]] Ehh you are ok considering that markets are good but the lack of egalitarianism in your pure forms is concerning sometimes....
*Military Interventions- In reality I am against any intervention outside of Stanistan but my liberal principles might accept it in some regard especially against Tankies
===Enemies===
===Enemies===
*[[File:Property.png]] [[Propertarianism]] - Why did you ruin the Lockean Proviso!?
*[[File:Property.png]] [[Propertarianism]] - Why did you ruin the Lockean Proviso!?
*[[File:Corp.png]] [[Corporatocracy]], [[File:Authcap.png]] [[Authoritarian Capitalism]], and [[File:Statecap.png]] [[State Capitalism]]- OH HECK NO!
*[[File:Corp.png]] [[Corporatocracy]], [[File:Authcap.png]] [[Authoritarian Capitalism]] & [[File:Statecap.png]] [[State Capitalism]] - OH HECK NO!
*[[File:Timocracy.png]] [[Timocracy]] - God created natural resources are for everyone, not just for you.
*[[File:Mao.png]] [[Maoism]] and [[File:Polpot.png]] [[Pol Potism]] - Should land be privately owned? No. Should landowners be murdered? ALSO NO!
*[[File:Nazi.png]] [[Nazism]] - Not THAT Steiner (both are not going to attack anyway).
*[[File:Kak.png]] [[Kakistocracy]]- Read some analytic philosophy you dimwit! Also stop invading spreading stupidity!


==Further Information==
==Further Information==
Line 79: Line 106:
*[[w:Hillel_Steiner|Hillel Steiner]] [[File:BertSocGeo.png]]
*[[w:Hillel_Steiner|Hillel Steiner]] [[File:BertSocGeo.png]]
===Literature===
===Literature===
*[https://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/phil_ex/vol39/iss1/1/ Left-Libertarianism as a Promising Form of Liberal Egalitarianism] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
*[https://pdfcoffee.com/hillel-steiner-an-essay-on-rights-1994-pdf-pdf-free.html An Essay on Rights] by [[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]]
⚫
*[https://mospace.umsystem.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/10355/10449/LeftLibertariansimAPrimer.pdf?sequence=1 Left-Libertarianism: A Primer] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
*[https://www.amazon.com/Left-Libertarianism-Its-Critics-Contemporary-Debate/dp/0312236999 Left-Libertarianism and Its Critics] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]] and [[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]]
*[https://www.amazon.com/Left-Libertarianism-Its-Critics-Contemporary-Debate/dp/0312236999 Left-Libertarianism and Its Critics] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]] and [[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]]
*[https://www.amazon.com/Essay-Rights-Hillel-Steiner/dp/0631190279 An Essay on Rights] by [[File:BertSocGeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Hillel Steiner]]
**[https://mospace.umsystem.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/10355/10449/LeftLibertariansimAPrimer.pdf?sequence=1 Left-Libertarianism: A Primer] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]] (Section from the above book)
*[https://klinechair.missouri.edu/docs/left_libertarianism_as_liberal_egalitarianism.pdf Left-Libertarianism as a Promising Form of Liberal Egalitarianism] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
⚫
*[https://klinechair.missouri.edu/docs/libertarianism_and_taxation.pdf Libertarianism and Taxation] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
*[https://klinechair.missouri.edu/docs/libertarianism_and_state_bg.pdf Libertarianism and the State] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
*[https://klinechair.missouri.edu/docs/child_liberationism.pdf Child Liberationism and Legitimate Interference] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]
*[https://klinechair.missouri.edu/docs/freedom_of_expression.pdf Freedom of Expression, Hate Speech, and Censorship] by [[File:Leftgeo.png]] [[Social Georgism|Peter Vallentyne]]


===Articles===
===Articles===
*[https://themutualist.wordpress.com/what-is-left-libertarianism What is Left-Libertarianism?]
*[https://themutualist.wordpress.com/what-is-left-libertarianism What is Left-Libertarianism?]
<references />
<references />

===Online Communities===
===Online Communities===
*[https://www.reddit.com/r/LeftGeorgism/ r/LeftGeorgism]
*[https://www.reddit.com/r/LeftGeorgism/ r/LeftGeorgism] [[File:Leftgeo.png]]


===Gallery===
===Gallery===
Line 102: Line 132:
{{Navbox/Liberals}}
{{Navbox/Liberals}}
{{Navbox/Libertarians}}
{{Navbox/Libertarians}}
{{Navbox/Welfareists}}
{{Navbox/Centrists}}
[[Category:Libertarians]]
[[Category:Libertarians]]
[[Category:Georgists]]
[[Category:Georgists]]
[[Category:Culturally Left]]
[[Category:Culturally Left]]
[[Category:Centrists]]

Latest revision as of 15:05, 15 March 2024

"If one also grants the importance of equality of life prospects, then equal opportunity left-libertarianism is, I claim, the most plausible version of libertarianism."

The Steiner-Vallentyne School is a Left Libertarian ideological school of thought. It bases its support for economically left-wing ideals in Classical Liberal, Georgist, and Physiocratic ideas on self-ownership, land appropriation, land ownership and the ownership of natural resources. It opposes the ownership of natural resources and land if such ownership acts as a detriment to others, and believes in state welfare programs and some form of wealth redistribution. Unlike many schools of left-libertarianism, the Steiner-Vallentyne school is not socialist, communist, or anarchist, as it is more moderate in its economically left-wing views.

History

Steiner Vallentyne School was developed by the ideas of Peter Vallentyne and Hilel Steiner who used Analytic Philosophy in order to solve solve issues regarding the apparent extremism of Libertarian Socialism. Now despite being very similar to Libertarian Social Georgism it is quite different in terms of in terms of origins as Steiner Vallentyne School was from mixing thoughts from Liberal ideologies and such. Also it is a separate ideology while Libertarian Social Georgism is a faction of Social Libertarianism.

How to draw

Flag of Steiner-Vallentyne School
  1. Draw a ball with 5 stripes; three of them red and 2 of them white.
  2. Draw a dark blue triangle positioned on the left and pointing to the right.
  3. Draw a white star inside the dark blue triangle.
  4. Add the eyes.

You're done!

Relationships

Friends

Frenemies

  • Libertarian Socialism - Sorry, but I think this might be a bit too far.
  • Social Liberalism - We both try to combined the principles of classical liberalism with egalitarian outcomes, but positive rights are a bit of a headache.
  • Geoanarchism - I'm not so sure about how you can maintain common land ownership in a stateless society, but it's the thought that counts. Also, please be less friendly with him.
  • Agrarian Socialism - I want land reform, too. But I don't think that socialism is necessary for that.
  • Tridemism - A little too authoritarian for me, but at least you were better than who came before you and especially those who came after you.
  • Ehh you are ok considering that markets are good but the lack of egalitarianism in your pure forms is concerning sometimes....
  • Military Interventions- In reality I am against any intervention outside of Stanistan but my liberal principles might accept it in some regard especially against Tankies

Enemies

Further Information

Wikipedia

Literature

Articles

Online Communities

Gallery

  • Better version

    Better version

Navigation

Retrieved from "https://polcompball.wiki/wiki/Steiner-Vallentyne_School?oldid=505446"