Jump to content

Confederalism: Difference between revisions

Seriously stop overusing non-anarchism. It should only be used if the ideology is both non-quadrant and is impossible to implement under an anarchist system. Confederalism doesn’t fit this definition.
No edit summary
(Seriously stop overusing non-anarchism. It should only be used if the ideology is both non-quadrant and is impossible to implement under an anarchist system. Confederalism doesn’t fit this definition.)
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
(110 intermediate revisions by 41 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{MessageBox/Stub}}
{{Ideology
|themecolor=999999
|title = [[File:Confed.png]] Confederalism
|textcolor=FFD700
|image = OłMejnOłMejnOfItsForDarForDiksie.png
|title=[[File:Confed.png]] Confederalism
|aliases = Confed <br> Confederal states <br> Anti-federalism (USA)<br>[[file:Fed-Steroids.png]] Federalism on steroids <br> [[File:Neoconfed.png]] Neo-Confederatism (USA, modern) <br> Alt-South Movement (USA)
|image=File:Confederalismbyvalvo.png
|alignments =
|caption="Wasn't it for states' rights <s>to own slaves</s>, lincolnite?"
[[File:Nonquadrant.png]] [[:Category:Non-Quadrant|Non-Quad]]<br>
|aliases=
[[File:Authright.png]] [[:Category:Authoritarian Right|AuthRight]] ([[File:Cball-CSA.png]] Confederatism)<br>
Confed<br>
[[File:Trad.png]] [[:Category:Culturally Right|Culturally Right]] ([[File:Cball-CSA.png]] Confederatism) <br>
Confederal states<br>
[[File:Libleft.png]] [[:Category:Libertarian Left|LibLeft]] ([[File: Demcon.png]] Left Confederalism) <br>
Anti-federalism (USA)<br>
[[File:Prgess.png]] [[:Category:Culturally Left|Culturally Left]] ([[File: Demcon.png]] Left Confederalism) <br>
[[File:Fed-Steroids.png]] Federalism on steroids<br>
|influences =
[[File:FeudCball-CSA.png]] [[Feudalism]]Confederatism (USA, historical)<br>
[[File:FedNeoconfed.png]] [[Federalism]]Neo-Confederatism (USA, modern)<br>
Alt-South Movement (USA)<br>
[[File:Monarch.png]] [[Monarchism]] (some) <br>
[[File:ConfedMon.png]] Confederate Monarchism (some)
|alignments=
[[File:Nonquadrant.png|link=:Category:Non-Quadrant]] [[:Category:Non-Quadrant|{{Color|#FFFFFF|'''Non-Quadrant'''}}]]<br>
'''Variants'''{{Collapse|
{{Info|Authoritarian Right|AuthRight}}([[File:Cball-CSA.png]] Confederatism)<br>
{{Info|Culturally Right}}([[File:Cball-CSA.png]] Confederatism)
}}
|influences=
[[File:Feud.png]] [[Feudalism]]<br>
[[File:Fed.png]] [[Federalism]]<br>
[[File:Monarch.png]] [[Monarchism]] (some)<br>
[[File:Republicanismpix.png]] [[Republicanism]] (most)<br>
[[File:Catheo.png]] [[Catholic Theocracy]] (Canada)<br>
|variantsschool =
*[[File:Cball-HRE.png]] '''HRE Model''' {{Collapse|
**[[File:Urb.png]] [[UrbismPatchwork]]
**[[File:Feud.png]] [[Feudalism]]
**[[File:Emon.png]] [[Elective Monarchism]]
Line 25 ⟶ 37:
**[[File:Calvinist_Theocracy.png]] {{PCBA|Calvinist Theocracy}} (1648–1806)
}}
*[[File:Cball-CSA.png]] '''{{Colorlink|#FFE680|Confederatism}}''' [[File:Cball-(VE)CSA.png]] {{Collapse|
**[[File:Authdem.png]] [[Authoritarian Democracy]]
**[[File:Herrenvolkdem.png]] [[Ethnocracy|Herrenvolk Democracy]]
**[[File:PrezIllibDem.png]] [[PresidentialismIlliberal Democracy]]
**[[File:Agrnac.png]] [[National Agrarianism]]
**[[File:Jacksonian Democracy.png]] [[Jacksonian Democracy]]
**[[File:Agrnac.png]] [[National Agrarianism]]
**[[File:Prez.png]] [[Presidentialism]]
**[[File:Res Publica.png]] [[Roman Republicanism]]
**[[File:Sep.png]] [[Separatism]]
**[[File: TotalitarianSlavery.png]] [[TotalitarianismCaste System|Slavery]] (debatably)[[File:8slave.png]]
**[[File:Slavery.png]] Slavery
**[[File:Whitesup.png]] [[White Nationalism]]
}}
|regional=
*[[File:JBuchanan.png]] '''(James) Buchananism''' {{Collapse|
**[[File:Anti-CSAAntife.png]] '''Anti-CSAFederalists''' {{Collapse|
**[[File:Anti-MormonAgCap.png]] Anti-Mormonism[[Agrarian Capitalism]]
**[[File:Constitutionalconservative1Thar.png]] [[ConstitutionalismAnti-Authoritarianism]]
**[[File:HamiltonianismClib.png]] [[Hamiltonianism|FederalistClassical PartyLiberalism]] (Initially)
**[[File:ImpDecentral.png]] [[ImperialismFederalism|Decentralization]]
**[[fileFile:KakLocal.png]] [[KakistocracyLocalism]]
**[[File:WignatPop.png]] [[White NationalismPopulism]]
**[[File:Jacksonian_DemocracyRepublicanismpix.png]] [[Jacksonian DemocracyRepublicanism]]
**[[File:HconRes Publica.png]] [[LGBTRoman ConservatismRepublicanism]] (Accused)
}}
**[[File:Slavery.png]] Pro-Slavery
[[File:Nullifiers.png]] '''Calhounism''' {{Collapse|
**[[File:Antiblack.png]] [[White Nationalism|Anti-Black Racism]]
**[[File:AntiEquality.png]] Anti-Egalitarianism
**[[File:AntiMil.png]] {{PCBA|Pacifism|Anti-Militarism}}
**[[File:Antiprotect.png]] Anti-Protectionism
**[[File:Econlib.png]] [[Fiscal Conservatism|Economic Liberalism]]
**[[File:Globcap.png]] [[Globalism|Free Trade]]
**[[File:Jeffersondem2.png]] [[Jeffersonian Democracy]]
**[[File:Local.png]] [[Localism]]
**[[File:Agrnac.png]] [[National Agrarianism]]
**[[File:Paternalism.png]] [[Paternalism]]
**[[File:Ultranalib.png]] [[National Liberalism|Ultranational Liberalism]]
**[[File:Slavery.png]] [[Caste System|Slavery]]
**[[File:ClibWhitesup.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|White Classical Liberalism]]
*'''Proto-Calhounism'''
**[[File:Fed.png]] [[Federalism]]
**[[File:Indust.png]] [[Industrialism]]
**[[File:Hamiltonianism.png]] [[Hamiltonianism]]
**[[File:Natcon.png]] [[National Conservatism]]
**[[File:Protect.png]] [[Protectionism]]
}}
*[[File:TylerJohnTyler.png]] '''John Tyler ThoughtDoctrine''' {{Collapse|
**[[File: TradconClassUSCon.png]] [[Classical Conservatism|American Whiggism]]
**[[File: Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]
**[[File:ImpJeffersondem2.png]] [[ImperialismJeffersonian Democracy]]
**[[File: Kak-Dunce.png]] [[Kakistocracy]] <ref>{{refn|Tyler's politicspolitical views got him kicked out of all the parties he was ever in</ref>.|group=Note}}
**[[File:Imp.png]] [[Imperialism|Manifest Destiny]]
**[[File:Mediocracy.png]] [[Mediocracy]]
**[[File: Moder.png]] [[Moderatism]]
**[[File: Natcon.png]] [[National Conservatism]]
**[[File:Nalib.png]] [[National Liberalism]]
}}
*[[File:Pierce.png]] '''Piercism''' [[File:JPierce.png]] {{Collapse|
**[[File:Abolitionism.png]] Abolitionism ([[File:JPierce.png]] Jane)
**[[File:Farm.png]] [[Agrarianism]] (Later on)
Line 67 ⟶ 100:
**[[File:Relreject.png]] [[Religious Rejectionism]] ([[File:JPierce.png]] Jane)
}}
|influenced={{Collapse|
*[[File:Cball-Novorossiya.png]] '''Novorossiya Project''' {{Collapse|
**[[File:Ukrainophobe.png]] Ukrainophobia
**[[File:FSB.png]] [[Ultranationalism|Girkinism]]
**[[File:Sep.png]] [[Separatism]]
}}
|influenced =
[[File:Altr.png]] [[Alt-Right]] (some)<br>
[[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism]]<br>
[[File:Tinismball.png]] {{PCBA|Tinism}}<br>
[[File:Dixiecrat.png]] [[White Nationalism|Dixiecratism]]<br>
[[File:Euskadi Carlism.png]] [[Euskadi Carlism]]<br>
[[File:Jacksonian Democracy.png]] [[Jacksonian Democracy]] (some)<br>
[[File:KKKJeffersondem2.png]] [[WhiteJeffersonian Nationalism|KKK ModelDemocracy]]<br>
[[File:MastrianoKKK.png]] [[Trumpism#MastrianoismWhite Nationalism|MastrianoismKlansmanism]]<br>
[[File:Zapa.png]] [[Neozapatismo]]<br>
[[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism]] (some)<br>
[[File:Paleolib.png]] [[Paleolibertarianism]]<br>
[[File:Puzzle_Piece_Politics-Icon.png]] [[Puzzle Piece Politics]]<br>
[[File:Urb.png]] [[UrbismPatchwork]]<br>
[[File:Whitesup.png]] [[White Nationalism]] (USA)<br>
}}
|theorists =
|theorists=[[File:PanAmer.png]] '''Americas''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:Native.png]] [[Indigenism|Dekanawidah]] (?-?) [[File:Cball-Iroquois Confederacy.png]] Iroquois Confederacy
*[[File:TradconNullifiers.png]] [[ClassicalWhite ConservatismNationalism|KlemensJohn vonC. MetternichCalhoun]] (17731782-18591850) [[File:Cball-GermanyUS.png]] The German Confederacy {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:WhitesupJohnTyler.png]] [[White NationalismImperialism|John C. CalhounTyler]] (17821790-18501862) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:TylerJBuchanan.png]] [[ImperialismKakistocracy|JohnJames TylerBuchanan]] (17901791-1862) (1782-18501868) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:JBuchananPierce.png]] [[ConstitutionalismAgrarianism|JamesFranklin BuchananPierce]] (17911804-18681869) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:PierceCball-(VE)CSA.png]] [[AgrarianismWhite Nationalism|FranklinRobert PierceE. Lee]] (18041807-18691870) [[File:Cball-US.png]] [[File:Cball-CSA.png]] USA/CSA
*[[File:SepWhitesup.png]] [[SeparatismWhite Nationalism|Jefferson Davis]] (1808-1889) [[File:Cball-US.png]] [[File:Cball-CSA.png]] USUSA/CSA
*[[File:Ethno.png]] [[Ethnocracy|Alexander H. Stephens]] (1812-1883) [[File:Cball-US.png]] [[File:Cball-CSA.png]] USUSA/CSA
*[[File:SepCball-CSA.png]] [[SeparatismWhite Nationalism|RobertJohn E.Wilkes LeeBooth]] (18071838-18701865) [[File:Cball-US.png]] [[File:Cball-CSA.png]] US/CSA{{PBW|USAball|USA}}
*[[File:Cball-CSAAbbott.png]] [[WhitePolice NationalismStatism|JohnGreg Wilkes BoothAbbott]] (18381957-1865) [[File:Cball-US.png]] {{PBW|USAball|USA}}
}}
*[[File:Austroliberalism-icon.png]] [[National Liberalism|Herbert Alois Krauss]] (1911-2008) [[File:Cball-Austria.png]] Austria
[[File:Cball-EU.png]] '''Europe''' {{Collapse|
*[[File:FSB.png]] [[Ultranationalism|Igor Girkin]] (1970-) [[File:Cball-Russia.png]] Russia
*[[File:Tradcon.png]] [[Classical Conservatism|Klemens von Metternich]] (1773-1859) [[File:Cball-GermanEmpire.png]] {{PBW|Germanyball|Germany}}
|examples =
*[[File:Austroliberalism-icon.png]] [[National Liberalism|Herbert Alois Krauss]] (1911-2008) [[File:Cball-Austria.png]] {{PBW|Austriaball|Austria}}
*[[File:Monarch.png]] [[Monarchism|The Three Crowned Kings]] ,1.050 B.C. as the first known example
*[[File:Yakovlevism.png]] [[Social Democracy|Alexander Yakovlev]] (1923-2005) [[File:Cball-Russia.png]] {{PBW|Russiaball|Russia}}
*[[File:Urb.png]] [[Urbism|The Delian League]] 478 BC-449 BC
*[[File:Strelkov.png]] [[Ultranationalism|Igor Girkin]] (1970-) [[File:Cball-Russia.png]] {{PBW|Russiaball|Russia}}
*[[File:Cball-Switzerland.png]] [[Isolationism|The Old Swiss Confederacy]] The 14th Century-1798
}}
*[[File:Cball-Iroquois Confederacy.png]] [[Indigenism|The Iroquois Confederacy]] 1450-1946
|examples=
*[[File:Arist.png]] [[Aristocracy|The German Confederation]] 1815-1866
*[[File:Triarchy.png]] [[Diarchy#Triarchy|The Three Crowned Kings]] (1050 BC as the first known example)
*[[File:ArgentinaFederalist.png]] [[Federalism|Argentine Confederation]] 1831-1861
*[[File:Cball-CSAAthdem.png]] [[WhiteAthenian NationalismDemocracy|The Confederate States ofDelian]] America[[Patchwork|League]] 1861(478 BC-1865449 BC)
*[[File:Cball-Swiss_Confederacy.png]] [[Isolationism|Old Swiss Confederacy]] (1291-1798)
|song = [https://youtu.be/_EHvcfvg1U0 Arise Donbass!] (In the [[File:Cball-Donetsk.png]][[File:Cball-Lugansk.png]] [[Kleptocracy#Vladimir_Putin|Donbass]])<br>
*[[File:Cball-Iroquois Confederacy.png]] [[Indigenism|Iroquois Confederacy]] (1450-1946)
*[[File:Cball-(NE)USA.png]] [[American Model|United States under the Articles of Confederation]] (1781-1789)
*[[File:PanGerman.png]] [[Pan-Nationalism#Pan-Germanism|German Confederation]] (1815-1866)
*[[File:German Empire.png]] [[Bismarckism|North German Confederation]] (1866-1871)
*[[File:Cball-Argentine Confederation.png]] [[Federalism|Argentine Confederation]] (1831-1861) (Self-proclaimed, debatably)
*[[File:Cball-CSA.png]] [[White Nationalism|The Confederate States of America]] (1861-1865)
|song=
[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VETGEFeNccs Confederacy of Independent Systems March: C.I.S. March]
[https://youtu.be/_EHvcfvg1U0 Arise Donbass!] (In the [[File:Cball-Donetsk.png]][[File:Cball-Lugansk.png]] [[Kleptocracy#Vladimir_Putin|Donbass]])<br>
[[File:Cball-CSA.png]] '''Confederatism'''
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wFNr9FnpZBkrQ1YQCMX_18 Dixie's Land]<br>
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s3d4SBVjgEs God Save the South]<br>
[[File:JBuchanan.png]] '''James Buchanan Thought'''
*[https://wwwyoutu.youtube.combe/watch?v=_k1uO_B7IzE Mrm36uOUSJFjE BeatOh -I'm TheA JamesGood BuchananOld SongRebel]<br>
*[https://wwwyoutu.youtube.combe/watch?v=dYsrXK4qSwULArGlfEVYqM The BuchananYellow andRose Johnof BreckenridgeTexas]<br>
[[File:TylerJohnTyler.png]] '''John Tyler ThoughtDoctrine'''
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTyz-cNML1I Mr Beat - The John Tyler Song]
*<s>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqYqvSiER00 John Tyler - "Everlasting"]</s><br>
Line 120 ⟶ 159:
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78v_zAtDEFM Pierce and King]
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dI1c6bZfiyc Rusty Cage - When I'm Drinkin' Whiskey]
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbtEkZIvMAg Alabama Song (Whisky Bar)]
|likes= State's rights
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCeLn19VkZY ABR - Join Us]
|likes= States' rights
|dislikes= Central authority telling him what to do
|themecolor=999999
|textcolor=FFD700
}}
'''Confederalism''' is a system where a group of regional governments are united under a weak confederal government for some purpose, but have equal or more power thenthan the confederal government. In some versions, regional governments might even have in-country tariffs, local militias, and strong borders. Of course, not all Confederalists support the [[File:Cball-CSA.png]] [[White Nationalism|CSA]].
 
== History ==
W.I.P
 
==Personality==
Confederate usually has split personalities whom he often argues with, and has trouble making decisions as a result. More negative depictions may have him justify acts that are stupid or malicious using states' rights.
 
==How to Draw==
{{Flag|Confed_flag.svg}}
 
# Draw a ball with eyes
# 5 red circles in aan X, the center circle can be bigger than the other 4, but it doesn't need to be
# 5 white circles in the red circles
# 5 blue stars in the white circles
# (Optional) confederate can be drawn as 5 separate balls, each with one of the circle-stars, usually arguing.
 
{{Flag-auto
|c1=White|h1=#FFFFFF
|h1=#FFFFFF
|c2=Red|h2=#D80323
|c2=Red
|c3=Blue|h3=#002368
|h2=#D80323
|c3=Blue
|h3=#002368
}}
 
Line 148 ⟶ 194:
*[[File:Libertarian.png]] [[Libertarianism]] & [[File:Libsoc.png]] [[Libertarian Socialism]] - Fellow decentralization fans. <s>Just please ignore my authoritarian variants such as CSA.</s>
*[[File:Minarchist.png]] [[Minarchism]] & [[File:Minsocf.png]] [[Minarcho-Socialism]] - Even bigger fans of decentralization. Based!
*[[File:Sep.png]] [[Separatism]] - Is a right of the states. <s>Except when it happens to me.</s>
*[[File:Helv.png]] [[Isolationism#Helvetic Model|Helvetic Model]] - Closer to federalism nowadays, but still pretty good.
*[[File:Demcon.png]] [[Democratic Confederalism]] - I support you against the Erdoganist and Kemalist unitarist.
*[[File:Cball-CSANeoconfed.png]] [[White Nationalism#Neo-Confederatism|Neo-Confederatism]] - I support you against Yankee tyrants too! <s>Wait, you are tyrannical too, especially to black people?</s>
*[[File:UKSNP.png]] [[Social Democracy|Scottish National Party]] - Based! Death to the unitarists in Westminster!
*[[File:Zapa.png]] [[Neozapatismo]] - Good job in Mexico son.
*[[File:Urb.png]] [[UrbismPatchwork]] - IStates' guessrights decentralinclude cities can workcity-states too.
*[[File:Feud.png]] [[Feudalism]] - The HRE was based.
*[[File:Jeffersondem2.png]] [[Jeffersonian Democracy]] - You get it, unlike that moron Hamilton.
*[[File:Agrnac.png]] [[National Agrarianism]] - The CSA was pretty cool too, although they gave me a bad rep with slavery.
*[[File:Nationalconservativeliberalism-icon.png]] [[National Liberalism|Irish Parliamentarianism]] - Your struggle is noble, shame how it all turned out.
 
===Frenemies===
Line 161 ⟶ 209:
*[[File:Fed.png]] [[Federalism]] - Too moderate. We need '''MOAR''' autonomy.
*[[File:European Federalism.png]] [[European Federalism]] - You're actually not ''too'' bad as you are currently, but the commission is a bunch of bureaucratic cringe.
*[[File: World_Federalism2.png]] [[World Federalism]] - DependsIt depends how much power the "states" have. And separatism is the right of the states you ignore.
*[[File:Consti.png]] [[Constitutionalism]] - Only good if it is for each individual state.
*[[File:Tradcon.png]] [[Classical Conservatism]] - Metternich was based but the American Whigs and British Tories were disgusting centralists.
*[[File:Radlib.png]] [[Radicalism]] - Paine and the Jeffersonians were decent but the Chamberlains and their "Liberal" Unionists were vile.
*[[File:Bism.png]] [[Bismarckism]] - The North German confederation was good while it lasted, such a shame it was meant to be temporary.
 
===Enemies===
*[[File:Unitary.png]] [[UnitarismCentralism]] - Stay away from my local authority.
*[[File: UnimonHamiltonianism.png]] [[Universal MonarchismHamiltonianism]] - 17761788 assholeNEVER FORGET! Death to imperialist hegemonies.
*[[File:Nalib.png]] [[National Liberalism]] - Lincolnite Tyrant! (Though the Irish Parliamentarianism was based.)
*[[File:IrishRepublican.png]] [[Left-Wing Nationalism|Irish Republicanism]] - Violent separation isn't good either.
 
==Further Information==
 
===Wikipedia===
 
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederation_Period |Confederation period]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Swiss_Confederacy |Old Swiss Confederacy]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tagsatzung |Tagsatzung]]
*[[wikipediaw:Swiss National Day|Swiss National Day]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederation |Confederation]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Dickinson |John Dickinson]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Confederation |German Confederation]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_States_of_America |Confederate States of America]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Federalism |Anti-Federalism]], [https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Administration_party |Anti-Administration party]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congress_of_the_Confederation |Congress of the Confederation]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/States%27_rights State's_rights|States' rights]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compact_theory |Compact theory]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_union |Personal union]]
*[https[w://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_union |Real union]]
*[https[w://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iroquois |Iroquois Confederacy]]
 
===Literature===
*[https://www.gilderlehrman.org/sites/default/files/inline-pdfs/T-04759.pdf Articles of the Confederation]
*[http://www.dircost.unito.it/cs/pdf/usa_confederate_1861_eng.pdf Confederate States of America provisional constitution]
*[http://www.documentarchiv.de/nzjh/dtba.html German confederation constitution]
 
===Notes===
{{Reflist|group=Note}}
 
===Reference===
<references />
 
==Gallery==
<gallery>
Eu Sou BR-3System.png|Credit: [[Eu Sou BR]], [https://www.reddit.com/r/Polcompball/comments/m536qn/third_party_system_and_reconstruction/ Source]
File:D4x7c110ni071.png|Credit: u/Pirate_Tails [https://old.reddit.com/r/Polcompball/comments/nhz83q/how_are_republicans_doing_today/ Source]
File:Confedball2 big 1-0.png
File:Confedball2 big 2-0.png|Original image
File:Confedball2 big 2.png
File:Confedball2 big 1.png
Confederal.png
OłMejnOłMejnOfItsForDarForDiksie.png
</gallery>
 
==Navigation==
{{Navbox/Nonquad}}
 
[[Category:Government Systems]]
 
4,356

edits

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.