Liberalism: Difference between revisions

{{Ideology

|themecolor=#006aa7

[[File:Lib.png]] Lib<br>

[[File:Lib.png]] Liberalism without adjectives<br>

{{Alias|Hindutva.png|Hindutva|Adarsh Liberal}}<br>

[[File:Authoritarian Conservatism.png]]/{{Alias|Fash.png|Fascism|[[File:LibCommie.png]] Communism}}<br>

[[File:Libtard.png]] Libtard (pejoratively)<br>

[[File:Liberal Democracy.png]] '''Liberal Democracy'''{{Collapse|

[[File:Demlib3.png]] Democratic Liberalism [[File:Libdem2.png]] (DemLib)<br>

[[File:Dem.png]] [[Democracy]] (By nearly everyone in the western world)<br>

[[File:WestDem.png]] Western Democracy<br>

}}

}}

{{Info|Capitalists}}<br>

[[File:Dem.png|link=:Category:Democratic]] [[:Category:Democratic|{{Color|#0C7AEA|'''De'''}}{{Color|#48CE48|'''mo'''}}{{Color|#E2E2E2|'''cra'''}}{{Color|#DD4949|'''tic'''}}]] (Most)<br>

{{Info|Liberals}}<br>

'''Sub-Ideologies'''<br>

[[File:L-lib.png]] '''Left-Liberalism''' [[File:Leftliberalism-icon.png]] {{Collapse|

[[File:Dem.png]] [[Democracy]] (Most)<br>

[[File:Enlightenment.png]] [[Enlightenment Thought]]<br>

[[File:Moder.png]] [[Moderatism]]

</div>

*[[File:Prog-u.png]] [[Progressivism]]

*[[File:Radlib.png]] [[Radicalism]]

*[[File:RegCap.png]] [[Regulationism|Regulated Capitalism]]

*[[File:Republicanismpix.png]] [[Republicanism]] (Most)

*[[File:RightSocDem.png]] [[Third Way|Right-Social Democracy]] (Some)

}}

*[[File:Civilib.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism|Civil Liberalism]]

*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]

*[[File:Libfem.png]] [[Liberal Feminism]]

*[[File:Radcent.png]] [[Radical Centrism]]

}}

[[File:Fukuyama.png]] '''Fukuyamaism''' {{Collapse|

*[[File:Anticommunism.png]] Anti-Communism

*[[File:AntiPutinism.png]] Anti-Putinism

*[[File:Antitrump.png]] Anti-Trumpism

*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] (Self-proclaimed)

*[[File:Neoliberal-icon.png]] [[Neoliberalism]]

*[[File:Soclib.png]] [[Social Liberalism]]

}}

[[File:RenewEurope.png]] '''Renew Europe''' {{Collapse|

*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]]

*[[File:Conlib.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism]]

*[[File:Neoliberal-icon.png]] [[Neoliberalism]]

*[[File:Soclib.png]] [[Social Liberalism]]

*[[File:Moder.png]] [[Moderatism]]

*[[File:Cball-EU.png]] [[European Federalism|Pro-Europeanism]]

}}

|influenced=

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bW4ZwyYJYbQ Battle Cry of Freedom]<br>

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iS1GpuLXCdI La Marseillaise]<br>

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0xPtsUeH_k Libtard Anthem]<br>[https://youtu.be/3cdqQ2BdgOA Love Me, I'm a Liberal]<br>

[https://youtu.be/rHAYFiwbGlY Biden's Paradise]<br>

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ciMhsof4mck Esto es lo que pienso de Francis Fukuyama]<br>

</div>

|theorists=

**[[File:Garfield.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|James A. Garfield]] (1831-1881)

**[[File:Cleveland.png]] [[Fiscal Conservatism|Grover Cleveland]] (1837-1908)

**[[File:FDRism-alt.png]] [[Social Liberalism|Franklin D. Roosevelt]] (1882-1945)

**[[File:Truman.png]] [[Social Liberalism|Harry S. Truman]] (1884-1972)

**[[File:JFK.png]] [[Social Liberalism|John F. Kennedy]] (1917-1963)

**[[File:JimmyCarter.png]] [[Social Liberalism|Jimmy Carter]] (1924-)

**[[File:Soros.png]] [[Plutocracy|George Soros]] (1930-)

**[[File:Nozick.png]] [[Libertarianism|Robert Nozick]] (1938-2002)

**[[File:Demcr.png]] [[Third Way|Nancy Pelosi]] (1940-)

**[[File:Bog.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Peter Boghossian]] (1966-)

**[[File:LouisCK.png]] [[Satirism|Louis C.K.]] (1967-)

**[[File:Mediastocracy flair.png]] [[Mediacracy|Rachel Maddow]] (1973-)

**[[File:Yang2020.png]] [[Social Libertarianism|Andrew Yang]] (1975-)

**[[File:Hcon.png]] [[Homoconservatism|Dave Rubin]] (1976-)

**[[File:Amash.png]] [[Libertarian Conservatism|Justin Amash]] (1980-)

**[[File:Conlib.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism|Brad Polumbo]] (1997-)

}}

*[[File:Cball-Commonwealth.png]] '''Commonwealth Realms'''{{Collapse|

}}

*[[File:Cball-EU.png]] '''Europe''' {{Collapse|

**[[File:Rousseau.png]] [[Enlightenment Thought|Jean-Jacques Rousseau]] (1712–1778) [[File:Cball-Switzerland.png]] Switzerland

**[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Wilhelm von Humboldt]] (1767-1835) [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussia

**[[File:Anti-Marx.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Heinrich Marx]] (1777-1838) [[File:Cball-Prussia.png]] Prussia

**[[File:LibKemSmall.png]] [[Kemalism|Fethi Okyar]] (1880-1943) [[File:ROT.png]] Türkiye

**[[File:Austrobert.png]] [[Austrian School|Ludwig von Mises]] (1881-1973) [[File:Cball-Austria.png]]

}}

}}

*[[File:PanAsian.png]] '''Asia''' {{Collapse|

**[[File:Chiang-Wei-Shui icon.png]] [[National Liberalism|Chiang]] [[Civic Nationalism|Wei-shui]] [[File:ChiangWeiShui2.png]] (1890-1931) [[File:Showa.png]] Empire of Japan Taiwan Colony

**[[File:Cball-EU.png]] [[European Federalism|Besim Tibuk]] (1945-) [[File:Cball-ROT.png]] Türkiye

**[[File:YeshAtid.png]] [[National Liberalism|Yair Lapid]] (1963-) [[File:Zio.png]] Israel

**[[File:Zehut.png]] [[National Libertarianism|Rafael Minnes]] (¿-) [[File:Zio.png]] Israel

}}

*[[File:Cball-AfricanUnion.png]] '''Africa''' {{Collapse|

}}

|likes=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">

</div>

|dislikes=<div style="overflow:auto; height:auto; max-height:200px; background:transparent;">

[[File:XiJinpingThoughtf.png]] [[Dengism|Xi Jinping]]<br>

[[File:KimJongUn.png]] [[Juche|Kim Jong-un]]<br>

[[File:Khameini.png]] [[Khomeinism|Ali Khamenei]]<br>

[[File:BJP.png]] [[Hindutva|Narendra Modi]]<br>

[[File:RecepTayyipErdogan.png]] [[Neo-Ottomanism|Recep Tayyip Erdoğan]]<br>

}}

|quote="Being all equal and independent, no one ought to harm another in his life, health, liberty, or possessions."

|speaker=[[File:JohnLocke.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|John Locke]]

The elements generally regarded as necessary for the development of a liberal state can be described as follows:

 

 

Other elements often found in liberal societies are:

 

 

 

==History==

WIP

WIP

 

==Beliefs==

===[[File:LibInternat.png]] Liberal Internationalism===

[[File:LiberalInternationalismFlag.png|thumb|220px|Flag of Liberal Internationalism]]

 

===[[File:SecLib.png]] Secular Liberalism===

===[[File:Liberal Democracy.png]] Liberal Democracy===

[[File:LiberalDemocracyFlag.png|thumb|220px|Flag of Liberal Democracy]]

 

<blockquote>''See: [[File:IllibDem.png]] [[Illiberal Democracy]]''</blockquote>

'''Authoritarian Liberal Democracy''' describes a hybrid regime combining elements from [[File:Liberal_Democracy.png]] [[Democracy|Liberal Democracy]] and [[File:Sec.png]] [[Authoritarianism]]. AuthLibDem governments entail power being concentrated in the hands of unaccountable officials—typically unelected [[File:Technocracy.png]] bureaucrats and [[File:Dem.png]] elected representatives who benefit from increased political apathy alike—which leads to a reduction in civil liberties. Local administrations, which tend to be the most democratic in the sense of high activity among citizens, end up being subservient to a [[File:Unitary.png]] highly centralized government, increasing political apathy. Liberal institutions which are supposed to be impartial actors (e.g., [[File:Krit.png]] courts) end up serving [[File:Parti.png]] partisan goals and their associated [[File:Crony.png]] special interest groups. AuthLibDem governments also empower [[File:PolState.png]] federal law enforcement agencies and routinely violate [[File:Civlibert.png]] civil or [[File:Consti.png]] constitutional rights (e.g., the Espionage Act and the Patriot Act, under [[File:Cball-US.png]] American Presidents [[File:Woodrow.png]] Woodrow Wilson and [[File:GHWB.png]] George H.W. Bush, respectively). It can be argued AuthLibDem regimes combine technocratic and electocratic elements.

You're done.

{{Flag-auto

}}

 

 

==Relationships==

 

*[[File:Enlightenment.png]] [[Enlightenment Thought]] - Grandpa! Thanks for teaching us all so much!

*[[File:Clib.png]] [[Classical Liberalism]] - Love you dad! Just regulate that economy a bit more, okay?

*[[File:Neoliberal-icon.png]] [[Neoliberalism]] & [[File:Chilib.png]] [[Chicago School]] - Sons, you helped preserve my ideas when the world was on the verge of forgetting them. You’re my primary ideological successors, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. <s>You also know more about economics than any of my other children.</s>

*[[File:Radlib.png]] [[Radicalism]] - I know you are just a SocLib who is no longer radical, but that's a good thing.

*[[File:Socdem.png]] [[Social Democracy]] - A little bit extreme at times, but I'm still really glad you prefer me over [[File:Soc-h.png]] [[Socialism|them]].

*[[File:Libconserv3.png]] [[Liberal Conservatism]] & [[File:Rockrep.png]] [[Rockefeller Republicanism]] - Tradition and freedom.

*[[File:Conlib.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism]] - Aren't you LibCon again? No? Oh well.

*[[File:Austrobert.png]] [[Austrian School]] & [[File:Hayek.png]] [[Hayekism]] - My laissez-faire loving relatives. <s>Shut up about the gold standard, will you?</s>

*[[File:ArizonaLib.png]] [[Bleeding-Heart Libertarianism|Arizona Liberalism]] - My peculiar relative...

*[[File:MusLib.png]] [[Interculturalism|Muscular Liberalism]] - My relative who wants everyone to get along a little better.

*[[File:Synclib.png]] [[Big Tent Liberalism]] - All liberals should work together! <s>Except [[File:Liberalsoc.png]] [[Liberal Socialism|you]] [[Reactionary Liberalism|two]] [[File:Reactlib.png]].</s>

*[[File:Liberaltarianism.png]] [[Liberaltarianism]] & [[File:Socliber.png]] [[Social Libertarianism]] - The best libertarians. Free markets and moderate social justice are the center of the democratic system.

*[[File:Neotech.png]] [[Technoliberalism]] & [[File:FDF-Pirate.png]] [[Piratism]] - Technology will enable common people to topple authoritarian regimes! <s>Wait, what do you mean the Arab Spring failed?</s>

*[[File:LibInternat.png]] [[Internationalism|Liberal Internationalism]] - Liberal international world order FTW! Long live the free-market world!

*[[File:Cdem.png]] [[Christian Democracy]] & [[File:Islamic Democracy.png]] [[Islamic Democracy]] - My religious children! <s>Even though the latter often degenerates into authoritarian ideologies like [[File:Ottoman.png]] [[Neo-Ottomanism|Erdoganism]].</s>

*[[File:Jeffersondem2.png]] [[Jeffersonian Democracy]] - My historical American adherent! <s>Free your slaves already, dammit.</s>

*[[File:Girondi.png]] [[Girondism]] & [[File:Feuillant.png]] [[Feuillantism]] - My French republican brothers.

*[[File:European Federalism.png]] [[European Federalism]] & [[File:Nordmodel.png]] [[Nordic Model]] - The European project is one of my biggest achievements, just federalize and get rid of some bureaucracies and you’ll be perfect.

*[[File:Helv.png]] [[Helvetic Model]] - See? This guy gets it.

 

===Frenemies===

*[[File:Conservative.png]] [[Conservatism]] - Our relationship is pretty odd indeed. We constantly fight each other over cultural policies but in terms of economics, we can agree [[File:Conlib.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism|some]][[Liberal Conservatism|times]] [[File:Libconserv3.png]].

*[[File:Libertarian.png]] [[Libertarianism]] - I respect his dedication to classical liberal principles, but he misunderstands the positive side of state power.

*[[File:Anlib2.png]] [[Anarcho-Capitalism|Anarcho-Liberalism]] & [[File:Panarchy.png]] [[Panarchism]] - You claim to be the full realization of my ideals, but how could we possibly maintain liberty without a state to maintain the rule of law?

**{{Alias|Anlib2.png|Anarcho-Capitalism|Through '''voluntary associations''', of course!}}

*[[File:Necon.png]] [[Neoconservatism]], [[File:Neobert.png]] [[Neo-Libertarianism]] & [[File:3way.png]] [[Third Way]] - They spread my ideals worldwide, but often in a manner that scares me.

*[[File:Nalib.png]] [[National Liberalism]] - A combination of liberalism and patriotism can be very productive indeed, but [[File:Ultranalib.png]] [[Ultranationalism|some]] of you push it past the point of rationality.

*[[File:Reactlib.png]] [[Reactionary Liberalism]] - I appreciate your support of free-market economics, but wanting to go back to the middle ages while supporting enlightened liberal values is weird and more similar to a proto-version of myself.

*[[File:ChiangKaiShek.png]] [[Tridemism|Chiang Kai-shek Thought]] - Lei Chen, Tsiang Tingfu, and Hu Shih supported you against the [[File:Mao.png]] [[Maoism|commies]], but why did you shut down the [[w:Free China Journal|Free China Journal]]? Also, the white terror was horrific.

*[[File:LDP(Japan).png]] [[Reactionary Liberalism#Japan|Japanese Liberal Democracy]] - Not the best example of my system but I have to admit you make Nippon a better place.

*[[File:Shapirocube.png]] [[Neo-Libertarianism|Shapiroism]] - Why do some people claim that you "destroy" us? You only hate my cultural aspects, but like my economic beliefs.

 

 

*[[File:Awaj.png]] [[Anarchism]] - Without a state, there is no constitution, and without a constitution is no right to consolidation.

*[[File:Authoritarian Conservatism.png]] [[Authoritarian Conservatism]] - So you want excessive communitarianism and limited freedom? No, thank you.

*[[File:Plcn2.png]] [[Paleoconservatism]] - Stop mixing religion and politics!

*[[File:Reactcross.png]] [[Reactionaryism]] - Why the f*ck do you want to return to the Dark Ages?!?

*[[File:Fash.png]] [[Fascism]] - Another genocidal maniac who oppressed a lot of people! <s>Wait, we had a [[File:Liberal Fascism.png]] [[National Capitalism|SON]]?!</s>

*[[File:ML.png]] [[Marxism–Leninism]] - A totally failed ideology that killed tens of millions. I especially hated [[File:Stalin.png]] him.

*[[File:Natcom.png]] [[National Communism]] - Moderate version of above.

*[[File:WelfChauvin.png]] [[Welfare Chauvinism]] - I must be looking into a hall of mirrors. <s>STOP POSING AS ME IN RUSSIA!</s>

*[[File:StateathFedora.png]] [[State Atheism]] - You're the same thing as a theocracy the only thing that changes is that you impose anti-theist beliefs instead of religious ones!

*[[File:Mao.png]] [[Maoism]] - Totalitarian genocidal commie who starved millions of his own people.

*[[File:Putin.png]] [[Kleptocracy|Putinism]] - Just like I won't forgive you for invading Ukraine. Also, Navalny is right, you're a party of crooks and thieves!

*[[File:Trumpism.png]] [[Right-Wing Populism|Trumpism]] - Ugh, disgusting. Please cool it with the protectionist populism.

===Literature===

 

 

*[https://historyofeconomicthought.mcmaster.ca/aristotle/Politics.pdf Politics] by [[File:Aristotle.png]] [[Athenian Democracy|Aristotle]]

*[https://openlibrary.org/books/OL7355261M/Discourses Discourses on Livy] by [[File:Niccolo Machiavelli.png]] [[Machiavellianism|Niccolò Machiavelli]]

*[https://cdn.mises.org/Politics%20of%20Obedience.pdf Discourse on Voluntary Servitude] by [[File:Thar.png]] [[Anti-Authoritarianism|Étienne de La Boétie]] | [https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLu5tKfQq0iyYx9z0Fno8evWOWfAn7DIWy Audiobook]

*[https://gutenberg.org/ebooks/608 Areopagitica] by [[File:ProtTheo.png]] [[Protestant Theocracy|John Milton]]

*[https://earlymoderntexts.com/authors/hobbes Leviathan] by [[File:Fishe.png]] [[Authoritarian Conservatism|Thomas Hobbes]]

*[https://socialsciences.mcmaster.ca/econ/ugcm/3ll3/locke/toleration.pdf A Letter Concerning Toleration] by [[File:JohnLocke.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|John Locke]]

*[https://www.ibiblio.org/ml/libri/s/SmithA_WealthNations_p.pdf The Wealth of Nations] by [[File:AdamSmith.png]] [[Classical Liberalism|Adam Smith]]

*[https://earlymoderntexts.com/assets/pdfs/wollstonecraft1792.pdf A Vindication of the Rights of Woman] by [[File:Wollstonecraft.png]] [[Liberal Feminism|Mary Wollstonecraft]] | [https://earlymoderntexts.com/mwaudio Audiobook]

*[https://eet.pixel-online.org/files/etranslation/original/Mill,%20On%20Liberty.pdf On Liberty] by [[File:Mill.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism|John Stuart Mill]] | [https://earlymoderntexts.com/jsmaudio Audiobook]

*[https://archive.ph/gfEqT What is a nation?] by [[File:ClibCivnat.png]] [[Civic Nationalism|Ernest Renan]] | [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cTT9sUGvFz4 Audio]

*[https://cactus.dixie.edu/green/B_Readings/I_Berlin%20Two%20Concpets%20of%20Liberty.pdf Two Concepts of Liberty] by [[File:Soclib.png]] [[Social Liberalism|Isaiah Berlin]]

*[https://archive.org/details/appealfromnewtoo00burkiala An Appeal from the New Whigs to the Old Whigs] by [[File:Burke.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism|Edmund Burke]]

*[https://wps.pearsoncustom.com/wps/media/objects/2429/2487430/pdfs/democracy.pdf Democracy in America] by [[File:AlexisdeTocqueville.png]] [[Conservative Liberalism|Alexis de Tocqueville]] | [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hb_QUVvlw3c Audiobook]

*[https://cdn.mises.org/Liberty%20or%20Equality%20The%20Challenge%20of%20Our%20Time_4.pdf Liberty or Equality: The Challenge of Our Time] by [[File:LiberMon.png]] [[Libertarian Monarchism|Erik von Kuehnelt-Leddihn]]

*[https://cdn.mises.org/Nation,%20State,%20and%20Economy_3.pdf Nation, State, and Economy] by [[File:Mises.png]] [[Austrian School|Ludwig Von Mises]]

 

==== [[File:L-lib.png]] Left-liberal theory ====

*[https://www.laits.utexas.edu/poltheory/jsmill/cos/cos.int.html On socialism] by [[File:Mill.png]] [[Civil Libertarianism|John Stuart Mill]]

*[https://books.google.com/books/about/Liberal_Socialism.html?id=V5srDgAAQBAJ&source=kp_book_description Liberal Socialism] by [[File:Liberalsoc.png]] [[Liberal Socialism|Carlo Rosselli]]

*[http://www.untag-smd.ac.id/files/Perpustakaan_Digital_1/DEMOCRACY%20The%20Crisis%20of%20Paliamentary%20Democracy.pdf The Crisis of Parliamentary Democracy] by [[File:CarlSchmitt.png]] [[Authoritarian Conservatism|Carl Schmitt]]

*[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism_and_the_Limits_of_Justice Liberalism and the Limits of Justice] by [[File:Community.png]] [[Communitarianism|Michael Sandel]]

*[https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/03/common-good-constitutionalism/609037/ Beyond Originalism] by [[File:Heart-Integralism.png]] [[Integralism|Adrian Vermeule]]

*[https://www.amazon.com/Liberalism-Critique-Principles-Various-Translation/dp/1999182715 Liberalism: A Critique of Its Basic Principles and Various Forms] by [[File:Integral Nationalism.png]] [[Integral Nationalism|S J Louis Cardinal Billot]]

*[https://www.amazon.com/Rise-Authoritarian-Liberal-Democracy/dp/1847183379 The Rise of Authoritarian Liberal Democracy] by [[File:POSTHUMANISMICON.png]] [[Post-Humanism|Peter Baofur]]

 

 

====Channels====

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC0jhtpmmIwPVIgdfpz5c3yw Arken the Amerikan] [[File:Clib.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://youtube.com/channel/UCHTnzqCT2rSs1_2HmZiVuRA Bastiat] [[File:Neoliberal-icon.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/c/Econoboi/videos Econoboi] [[File:Econoboi.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/user/FreeToChooseNetwork Free To Choose Network] [[File:ChicagoLib.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCihTFVasF5brNjL-UyIfrcQ Liberal Sanity Project] [[File:3way.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/@realryanchapman Ryan Chapman] [[File:Soclib.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/@StardustStreams Stardust] [[File:Leftneolib.png]]

*[[File:Cball-US.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5Dw9TFdbPJoTDMSiJdIQTA Whatifalthist] [[File:ConClib.png]]

*[[File:Cball-UK.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/@RoseofDawn Rose of Dawn] [[File:Truscum.png]]

*[[File:Cball-UK.png]] [https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC0p5jTq6Xx_DosDFxVXnWaQ The Economist] [[File:Econlib.png]]

*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lqQsogGTs-s How Classical Liberalism became Libertarianism] by [[File:Libcon.png]] [[Libertarian Conservatism|Casual Historian]]

*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KO8OxfFiVv8 Liberalism: where did it come from and are its days numbered?] by [[File:Econlib.png]] [[Mediacracy|The Economist]]

*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w38t-NhrADM The Folly of Liberal History] by [[File:RightSocDem.png]] [[Third Way|Kraut]]

 

===Wikipedia===

 

 

=== Organizations ===

Liberal.png

Liberalism-03.png

L176dj0624d41.png

Duyphysics-1939.png|Credit: u/duy_physics, [https://www.reddit.com/r/Polcompball/comments/jrolu2/ideological_world_map_1939/ Source]

{{Navbox/Capitalists}}

{{Navbox/Liberals}}

[[Category:Status Quo]]

[[Category:Culturally Left]]